Sales Tax in NC: The Impact of the Latest Decision of the Supreme Court

by | Jun 14, 2018 | Blog, Taxes | 0 comments

North Carolina has relatively stable and low sales tax rates for a mid-Atlantic state with nearly 8 million residents. The state’s general sales tax rate is 4.75% and depending on the city/county you are purchasing in, the local taxes can range from 4.8% to 8.25%.

North Carolina has relatively stable and low sales tax rates for a mid-Atlantic state with nearly 8 million residents. The state’s general sales tax rate  is 4.75% and depending on the city/county you are purchasing in, the local taxes can range from 4.8% to 8.25%.

However, these local sales tax rates can be affected by federal court decisions, like the latest hearing by the Supreme Court this April. The case could be settled in several different ways, but it ultimately will come down to one of two outcomes: in favor of South Dakota, which means that online retailers will now be the sales tax police; or for Wayfair, which means that Congress will need legislation to address the issue.

Sales Taxes explained

Before we go into details, a brief overview of sales taxes and how they work:

In most of the USA, sales taxes are transaction type of taxes that are placed on the sale (or in some cases on the lease) of services and goods in a county/city/state. If you purchase something in a place that levies sales tax, the seller will add the tax onto your total purchase and the tax is paid with the transaction. This transaction type of tax contrasts against property taxes or income taxes in who pays them. If you don’t own property (real estate, a car, or boat), then you likely are not paying property taxes; however, the moment you purchase something, sales taxes are paid. There are 45 US states that have sales taxes, including the great state of North Carolina. This state also has some selective sales taxes on the sale of specific products, like boats, cars, planes, and certain grocery items. Generally speaking, these taxes are calculated in a simple way: the purchase price is multiplied by the corresponding tax rate.

While most consumers and business owners know what sales tax is, use tax will draw questions and blank looks.  It’s important to know that the seller is supposed to collect the tax at the time of sale (this is most important when selling online). On the other hand, use tax is self-assessed by the buyer who didn’t pay sales tax (it’s the same rate). So when selling items to NC residents, the seller should collect sales taxes from the buyer and if the seller does NOT charge sales tax then the buyer should “self-assess” the use tax.

Nexus

When we are discussing the sales taxes in North Carolina we also have to mention the term “nexus”, which is the technical term representing “the responsibility to collect sales taxes within a state/county/city.” This is an important issue for businesses that are present in multiple states, as states may assess their states’ sales taxes on sales that are not otherwise taxed in another state. Nexus for sales tax purposes in NC is mostly based on physical presence, whether its an office, employee, contractor, agent, or even a warehouse. From that basic definition, it gets complicated based on what the item being sold is and the possibilities for nexus are too vast to mention for these purposes.

However, one other important aspect of nexus iis that North Carolina is a destination-based state for purposes of making a taxable sale. This means that North Carolina residents are collecting sales taxes at the rate of the location where the business is located. In other words, a Charlotte (CLT) retailer collects sales tax at the local CLT rate, but if a retailer in Raleigh sells/ships a product to a customer in CLT, then the sales taxes collected should be at the CLT rate.

The potential for changes by a decision by the Supreme Court in Wayfair v. South Dakota

As many experts have pointed out (GMP CPA included), this case is basically a clash between brick and mortar retailers and online retailers that will have an impact on states, businesses and ordinary people. Interestingly enough, North Carolina doesn’t rely as much on sales tax collection as other states, especially since NC has a statewide income tax collected through payroll deductions. According to NC publically available data on overall state revenue collections, the percent of state revenue from sales taxes in NC is less than 30%. For reference, there are states that rely on almost half of their annual budget (45%) from sales tax collections. If the court rules in favor of the states, North Carolina would stand to gain millions of dollars in tax revenue and force out-of-state retailers to have “nexus” for NC sales taxes. Of course, many large companies were already complying with these concepts, but smaller Amazon, Ebay, Etsy and other online retailers were under the radar and offering a slight price advantage by taking advantage of the lack of a court ruling. A side effect of this decision could subject smaller online retailers to an massive compliance burden that could force them to register for sales taxes in all states that they customers in. Having to comply with all the sales tax laws for each and every state would likely drive some small businesses out of the market or mad (or both!).

The final decision in this case is scheduled for this June and those of us at GMP CPA are getting anxious about the outcome. It’s not too late to get ahead of the Supreme Court decision, whichever way it goes, and start making changes to your business to be compliant. We would be happy to take at look at your current sales tax calculations and give you a pat on the back or steer you toward a better way. Don’t wait until an audit or notice from the state, contact Gary M Prusiensky, CPA PC now.

MORE ARTICLES FROM OUR BLOG

QBI walkthrough for our clients

Dear Client:Your ownership of a pass-through trade or business can generate a Section 199A tax deduction of up to 20 percent of your qualified business income (QBI). The C corporation does not generate this deduction, but the proprietorship, partnership, S...

Are you living in the most tax-friendly state?

If you live in New England, New Jersey, New York, or California, an info-graphic confirms the pain you experience when it comes paying high state taxes (income AND sales taxes). Oddly enough, Minnesota took the top spot of most expensive state taxes in the US and...

GMP CPA Business Advisor

GMP CPA recently met with a prospective client and when the topic of being a business advisor came up, we heard an interesting point of view. The potential client was specifically looking for a professional that would offer more than [just] tax & accounting...

Test your knowledge about NC Sales Tax for HVAC Services

If your business involves repairs, maintenance, or installation services related to vehicles then this quiz will test your knowledge of current NC sales tax law. More from our blog:

Cost segregation

Dear GMP CPA Client: Cost segregation is the magic sauce that breaks your real property into its components and some of these components can depreciate much faster than the typical overall standard 27.5 or 39 year periods. This magic sauce is brought you courtesy of a...
How do I become an S-corporation?
Test your knowledge about NC Sales Tax for HVAC Services